ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

Anything not related to modelling
Post Reply
User avatar
Stokesy44
Major General
Major General
Posts: 8679
Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
Location: The Midlands, UK
Great Britain

ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

Post by Stokesy44 »

We've had an outbreak of submarine builds here on the forum. Along with this came a lot of references to 'The Hunt for Red October', a cracker of a cold war thriller in my opinion.

So if we were to organize a weekly movie night (which we're not ;) ), what would you want to break out the popcorn for? And before you ALL go there, nothing smutty Gents!

Many of us are history buffs in some form or other and that informs our modelling choices so in line with that, what are the movies that dovetail into your interests?

If you're a cars and bikes kind of guy would you ask for Ford v Ferrari, or maybe Rush? Or maybe Chitty Chitty Bang Bang :lol: :lol: :lol:

And there's always Sci-Fi, need I say more.

With great power comes great responsibility. If you nominate a film, please explain why. Its all subjective. Movies are neither good nor bad, your opinion is your own. And feel free to comment on others' choices, jump on if you agree or say why if you dont.

I'll kick it off, one of my top 10.

Image

Released in 1995, I thought it was brilliantly filmed and acted. The fact they shot a lot of it in zero G adds real authenticity to the visuals. Its faithful to what happened both from an event point of view but also from the technical side. And even though we know the outcome before hand, it is suspenseful right up to splashdown.

I thought the launch was a superb sequence after the director refused to use any stock NASA footage. CGI was only in its infancy and much of the launch uses traditional model shooting.

I also liked the way the movie is split between the events on the ground and in space, for me, its a movie where you cant help but roof for everyone. It makes you feel GOOD and the outcome is all the sweeter for it.

It was also a fantastic film to see at the cinema on the big screen!

It stoked my interest in the space race and I've lost count of how many times I have watched it and all the extras on the DVD.
Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
User avatar
RangerNeil
Captain
Captain
Posts: 4581
Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2019 9:42 pm
Location: Dagenham
Contact:
Great Britain

Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

Post by RangerNeil »

Going back to submarines - ĥow about:
Image

K19 - The Widowmaker. A true story - the film stays relatively faithful to what happened aboard the K19 when it had a reactor incident (it was a Hollywood version of a Soviet incident after all) and does, in my opinion capture the fear and tension felt by the crew most of whom would have viewed the reactor as the instrument of the devil as well as the tensions between the captain and his XO. Not to mention the side-effects suffered by those who had to go into the reactor space to repair the cooling system. You do get a sense of how the teams who had to go in after the first one, and saw how the radiation had affected them but went in anyway, felt. They had no Rad Suits, only NBC kit, which was about as much use as a wet paper bag.
    Neil (yet another one...)

    On the board now:

    Airfix 1/35 Alvis Stalwart Mk2 FV622
    Hobby Boss 1/350 Surcouf
    Hobby Boss 1/350 Soviet Alfa class
    Hobby Boss 1/350 USN Los Angeles
    Mikro Mir 1/350 HMS M1


    Scalemates stash info
    =58417&fkSTASHSTATUS[]=58417-Stash&page=stash]Scalemates Stash manager
    User avatar
    Stokesy44
    Major General
    Major General
    Posts: 8679
    Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
    Location: The Midlands, UK
    Great Britain

    Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

    Post by Stokesy44 »

    RangerNeil wrote: Thu Feb 19, 2026 12:37 am Going back to submarines - ĥow about:
    Image

    K19 - The Widowmaker. A true story - the film stays relatively faithful to what happened aboard the K19 when it had a reactor incident (it was a Hollywood version of a Soviet incident after all) and does, in my opinion capture the fear and tension felt by the crew most of whom would have viewed the reactor as the instrument of the devil as well as the tensions between the captain and his XO. Not to mention the side-effects suffered by those who had to go into the reactor space to repair the cooling system. You do get a sense of how the teams who had to go in after the first one, and saw how the radiation had affected them but went in anyway, felt. They had no Rad Suits, only NBC kit, which was about as much use as a wet paper bag.
    Ford & Neeson, you cant go wrong with those two. I remember the harrowing radiation scenes and the bravery of the crew. Gripping stuff.

    Now we need someone to nominate Crimson Tide!
    Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
    User avatar
    Tomcat64
    Brigadier General
    Brigadier General
    Posts: 7151
    Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2016 3:24 pm
    Location: Swindon, UK
    England

    Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

    Post by Tomcat64 »

    Two great movies already mentioned.

    I seem to have unconsciously become a bit of a Tom Hanks fan over the years and really enjoy a lot of the movies he's been in: Apollo 13 as already mentioned, The Green Mile, Captain Phillips, Bridge of Spies, Sully and of course Shaving Ryan's Privates :)

    I also like a lot of Liam Neeson's stuff and if you want a gangster type movie with a twist and plenty of dark humour give Cold Pursuit a try
    Cheers, Neil

    On the Bench:
    Revell 1/72 Millennium Falcon - stalled due to stupidity
    Tamiya 1/35 Stegosaurus Stenops
    Tamiya 1/35 Sherman Firefly VC
    User avatar
    RangerNeil
    Captain
    Captain
    Posts: 4581
    Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2019 9:42 pm
    Location: Dagenham
    Contact:
    Great Britain

    Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

    Post by RangerNeil »

    Stokesy44 wrote: Thu Feb 19, 2026 7:40 am
    RangerNeil wrote: Thu Feb 19, 2026 12:37 am Going back to submarines - ĥow about:
    Image

    K19 - The Widowmaker. A true story - the film stays relatively faithful to what happened aboard the K19 when it had a reactor incident (it was a Hollywood version of a Soviet incident after all) and does, in my opinion capture the fear and tension felt by the crew most of whom would have viewed the reactor as the instrument of the devil as well as the tensions between the captain and his XO. Not to mention the side-effects suffered by those who had to go into the reactor space to repair the cooling system. You do get a sense of how the teams who had to go in after the first one, and saw how the radiation had affected them but went in anyway, felt. They had no Rad Suits, only NBC kit, which was about as much use as a wet paper bag.
    Ford & Neeson, you cant go wrong with those two. I remember the harrowing radiation scenes and the bravery of the crew. Gripping stuff.

    Now we need someone to nominate Crimson Tide!
    Or even "Das Boot"!!
      Neil (yet another one...)

      On the board now:

      Airfix 1/35 Alvis Stalwart Mk2 FV622
      Hobby Boss 1/350 Surcouf
      Hobby Boss 1/350 Soviet Alfa class
      Hobby Boss 1/350 USN Los Angeles
      Mikro Mir 1/350 HMS M1


      Scalemates stash info
      =58417&fkSTASHSTATUS[]=58417-Stash&page=stash]Scalemates Stash manager
      User avatar
      Stokesy44
      Major General
      Major General
      Posts: 8679
      Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
      Location: The Midlands, UK
      Great Britain

      Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

      Post by Stokesy44 »

      Tomcat64 wrote: Thu Feb 19, 2026 11:15 am Two great movies already mentioned.

      I seem to have unconsciously become a bit of a Tom Hanks fan over the years and really enjoy a lot of the movies he's been in: Apollo 13 as already mentioned, The Green Mile, Captain Phillips, Bridge of Spies, Sully and of course Shaving Ryan's Privates :)

      I also like a lot of Liam Neeson's stuff and if you want a gangster type movie with a twist and plenty of dark humour give Cold Pursuit a try
      Big Tom Hanks fan myself. I'll have to do a recommendation on Saving Private Ryan (its real name!) because the movie had quite an effect on me, so much so I've found myself in France 4 times touring Normandy! :crazy:
      Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
      NoelSmith
      Sergeant First Class
      Sergeant First Class
      Posts: 313
      Joined: Sat Feb 21, 2015 2:35 pm
      Great Britain

      Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

      Post by NoelSmith »

      Hunt for Red October. One of Clancey's best.

      Das Boot. For real claustrophobic atmosphere. Real twist at the end !

      Fiction, but both enjoyable films to watch
      User avatar
      DRUMS01
      Chief Warrant Officer 3
      Chief Warrant Officer 3
      Posts: 2251
      Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2016 1:48 am
      Location: Ohio, USA
      United States of America

      Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

      Post by DRUMS01 »

      I'm going to break away from the submarine and nautical theme and go with something like, "A Bridge too Far", or possibly one of these:

      All quiet on the Western Front
      Apollo 17
      Band of Brothers
      On the table or recently completed:

      1/18 AV8-B Harrier - WIP
      1/35 Churchill AVRE with SBG Bridge Diorama - DONE
      75mm BMW R75 WW2 motorcycle with rider - DONE
      User avatar
      RangerNeil
      Captain
      Captain
      Posts: 4581
      Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2019 9:42 pm
      Location: Dagenham
      Contact:
      Great Britain

      Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

      Post by RangerNeil »

      DRUMS01 wrote: Tue Feb 24, 2026 2:57 pm I'm going to break away from the submarine and nautical theme and go with something like, "A Bridge too Far", or possibly one of these:

      All quiet on the Western Front
      Apollo 17
      Band of Brothers
      Apollo 17?? Did they get that far?
        Neil (yet another one...)

        On the board now:

        Airfix 1/35 Alvis Stalwart Mk2 FV622
        Hobby Boss 1/350 Surcouf
        Hobby Boss 1/350 Soviet Alfa class
        Hobby Boss 1/350 USN Los Angeles
        Mikro Mir 1/350 HMS M1


        Scalemates stash info
        =58417&fkSTASHSTATUS[]=58417-Stash&page=stash]Scalemates Stash manager
        User avatar
        Stokesy44
        Major General
        Major General
        Posts: 8679
        Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
        Location: The Midlands, UK
        Great Britain

        Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

        Post by Stokesy44 »

        NoelSmith wrote: Thu Feb 19, 2026 8:47 pm Hunt for Red October. One of Clancey's best.

        Das Boot. For real claustrophobic atmosphere. Real twist at the end !

        Fiction, but both enjoyable films to watch
        I love Red October. Das Boot is is a real tour de force of just how scary it must have been to crew those WW2 subs. All the tension and claustrophobia, couped up in those conditions. :crazy:
        Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
        User avatar
        DRUMS01
        Chief Warrant Officer 3
        Chief Warrant Officer 3
        Posts: 2251
        Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2016 1:48 am
        Location: Ohio, USA
        United States of America

        Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

        Post by DRUMS01 »

        Oops, Apollo 13…. Silly me.

        Actually Apollo 17 was the last moon landing.
        On the table or recently completed:

        1/18 AV8-B Harrier - WIP
        1/35 Churchill AVRE with SBG Bridge Diorama - DONE
        75mm BMW R75 WW2 motorcycle with rider - DONE
        User avatar
        Stokesy44
        Major General
        Major General
        Posts: 8679
        Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
        Location: The Midlands, UK
        Great Britain

        Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

        Post by Stokesy44 »

        DRUMS01 wrote: Tue Feb 24, 2026 6:33 pm Oops, Apollo 13…. Silly me.

        Actually Apollo 17 was the last moon landing.
        I have to agree with all your choices. Apollo 13, a great movie and so accurate too. Nothing touches Band of Brothers although I thought The Pacific was very impressive too. The latest one, Masters of the Air was good but it could have been great. They tried to do too much with too few episodes.

        I haven't seen the new version of All Quiet on the Western front but the reviews and exerts I have seen look really good.

        I really like a Bridge Too Far, the last of the great ensemble films. The only issue I have with it is that it leaves so much out, particularly with the US Airborne divisions. Its also a bit anti-British to be honest. Still a good movie though.
        Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
        User avatar
        RangerNeil
        Captain
        Captain
        Posts: 4581
        Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2019 9:42 pm
        Location: Dagenham
        Contact:
        Great Britain

        Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

        Post by RangerNeil »

        Stokesy44 wrote: Wed Feb 25, 2026 6:37 am
        DRUMS01 wrote: Tue Feb 24, 2026 6:33 pm Oops, Apollo 13…. Silly me.

        Actually Apollo 17 was the last moon landing.
        I have to agree with all your choices. Apollo 13, a great movie and so accurate too. Nothing touches Band of Brothers although I thought The Pacific was very impressive too. The latest one, Masters of the Air was good but it could have been great. They tried to do too much with too few episodes.

        I haven't seen the new version of All Quiet on the Western front but the reviews and exerts I have seen look really good.

        I really like a Bridge Too Far, the last of the great ensemble films. The only issue I have with it is that it leaves so much out, particularly with the US Airborne divisions. Its also a bit anti-British to be honest. Still a good movie though.
        I took my father to see "A bridge too far" at the local odeon. He wasn't impressed - to the point about halfway through he was saying things like "that didn't happen" or "it didn't happen that way". Guy a couple of seats along from me turned and said to me thinking it was me saying it "how come you're such an expert" - dad leant around, gave him the stinkeye and snapped "because I was bl**dy well there".
        In fairness once the film finished the guy apologised to dad.
          Neil (yet another one...)

          On the board now:

          Airfix 1/35 Alvis Stalwart Mk2 FV622
          Hobby Boss 1/350 Surcouf
          Hobby Boss 1/350 Soviet Alfa class
          Hobby Boss 1/350 USN Los Angeles
          Mikro Mir 1/350 HMS M1


          Scalemates stash info
          =58417&fkSTASHSTATUS[]=58417-Stash&page=stash]Scalemates Stash manager
          User avatar
          Stokesy44
          Major General
          Major General
          Posts: 8679
          Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
          Location: The Midlands, UK
          Great Britain

          Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

          Post by Stokesy44 »

          RangerNeil wrote: Wed Feb 25, 2026 9:19 am
          I took my father to see "A bridge too far" at the local odeon. He wasn't impressed - to the point about halfway through he was saying things like "that didn't happen" or "it didn't happen that way". Guy a couple of seats along from me turned and said to me thinking it was me saying it "how come you're such an expert" - dad leant around, gave him the stinkeye and snapped "because I was bl**dy well there".
          In fairness once the film finished the guy apologised to dad.
          That must have been a sweet moment!
          Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
          User avatar
          Stokesy44
          Major General
          Major General
          Posts: 8679
          Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
          Location: The Midlands, UK
          Great Britain

          Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

          Post by Stokesy44 »

          As Monty Python said, And now for something completely different.

          Since Sci-Fi is a recognised stream for modelling, its time to tackle the big questions. First up:

          Image

          My thoughts.

          The best Star Wars film

          One of the best sequels ever made

          One of the best films ever made

          That's my opinion, let the games begin...... :th:
          Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
          User avatar
          cor
          Warrant Officer
          Warrant Officer
          Posts: 1325
          Joined: Sun May 23, 2021 10:34 am
          Location: Sydney, Australia
          Australia

          Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

          Post by cor »

          Yes, sci fi. A few classics to begin with

          The Fifth Element

          John Carpenters The Thing

          Blade Runner

          Rouge One

          Independence Day

          Just off the top of my head......
          User avatar
          Stokesy44
          Major General
          Major General
          Posts: 8679
          Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
          Location: The Midlands, UK
          Great Britain

          Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

          Post by Stokesy44 »

          cor wrote: Fri Feb 27, 2026 2:17 am Yes, sci fi. A few classics to begin with

          The Fifth Element

          John Carpenters The Thing

          Blade Runner

          Rouge One

          Independence Day

          Just off the top of my head......
          Wow, that's quite a selection! Great movies although I've never actually seen The Thing. Seen plenty about it, just never watched it. Good to see Rogue One getting a mention too. Definitely the best of the new SW movies by far.

          And what about Blade Runner 2049? I thought it was a great sequel, despite it not doing well on release. Critics loved it but audiences just didn't turn up.
          Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
          User avatar
          RangerNeil
          Captain
          Captain
          Posts: 4581
          Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2019 9:42 pm
          Location: Dagenham
          Contact:
          Great Britain

          Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

          Post by RangerNeil »

          Showing the age here - but - what about the classic sci-fi film 2001 A Space Oddysey??
            Neil (yet another one...)

            On the board now:

            Airfix 1/35 Alvis Stalwart Mk2 FV622
            Hobby Boss 1/350 Surcouf
            Hobby Boss 1/350 Soviet Alfa class
            Hobby Boss 1/350 USN Los Angeles
            Mikro Mir 1/350 HMS M1


            Scalemates stash info
            =58417&fkSTASHSTATUS[]=58417-Stash&page=stash]Scalemates Stash manager
            User avatar
            Stokesy44
            Major General
            Major General
            Posts: 8679
            Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
            Location: The Midlands, UK
            Great Britain

            Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

            Post by Stokesy44 »

            RangerNeil wrote: Fri Feb 27, 2026 9:23 pm Showing the age here - but - what about the classic sci-fi film 2001 A Space Oddysey??
            I've seen so many clips of it but I dont think I have ever sat down and watched it properly. it seems a bit forced to me, a bit po-faced. That might be because I'm familiar with it without having had the experience of watching it. Its almost universally respected so I'm obviously wrong! :lol:
            Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
            User avatar
            cor
            Warrant Officer
            Warrant Officer
            Posts: 1325
            Joined: Sun May 23, 2021 10:34 am
            Location: Sydney, Australia
            Australia

            Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

            Post by cor »

            Stokesy44 wrote: Fri Feb 27, 2026 1:33 pm
            cor wrote: Fri Feb 27, 2026 2:17 am Yes, sci fi. A few classics to begin with

            The Fifth Element

            John Carpenters The Thing

            Blade Runner

            Rouge One

            Independence Day

            Just off the top of my head......
            Wow, that's quite a selection! Great movies although I've never actually seen The Thing. Seen plenty about it, just never watched it. Good to see Rogue One getting a mention too. Definitely the best of the new SW movies by far.

            And what about Blade Runner 2049? I thought it was a great sequel, despite it not doing well on release. Critics loved it but audiences just didn't turn up.

            You gotta see the thing. Classic.

            Also check out They Live. Great John Carpenter social commentary.

            Br 2049 was ok, but not really a great movie imho
            User avatar
            Stokesy44
            Major General
            Major General
            Posts: 8679
            Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
            Location: The Midlands, UK
            Great Britain

            Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

            Post by Stokesy44 »

            cor wrote: Sat Feb 28, 2026 8:00 am
            You gotta see the thing. Classic.

            Also check out They Live. Great John Carpenter social commentary.

            Br 2049 was ok, but not really a great movie imho
            Yeah, I reckon The Thing is on my watchlist. I haven't seen much from John Carpenter although I really enjoyed Starman.

            As for the Blade Runner sequel, its all about opinion at the end of the day. One of my mates is a big fan of the new Dune films. I've seen them but they left me cold, I could appreciate the quality but I just couldn't get into it. It was still nice to go to the cinema though. You cant beat the big screen at the end of the day.
            Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
            User avatar
            cor
            Warrant Officer
            Warrant Officer
            Posts: 1325
            Joined: Sun May 23, 2021 10:34 am
            Location: Sydney, Australia
            Australia

            Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

            Post by cor »

            Stokesy44 wrote: Sat Feb 28, 2026 8:25 am
            cor wrote: Sat Feb 28, 2026 8:00 am
            You gotta see the thing. Classic.

            Also check out They Live. Great John Carpenter social commentary.

            Br 2049 was ok, but not really a great movie imho
            Yeah, I reckon The Thing is on my watchlist. I haven't seen much from John Carpenter although I really enjoyed Starman.

            As for the Blade Runner sequel, its all about opinion at the end of the day. One of my mates is a big fan of the new Dune films. I've seen them but they left me cold, I could appreciate the quality but I just couldn't get into it. It was still nice to go to the cinema though. You cant beat the big screen at the end of the day.
            Dune bored me.
            The Thing and They Live are very different to Starman.

            Here's a great one
            Strange Days. Reiphe Fiennes and Angela Bassett. Cyberpunk
            User avatar
            RangerNeil
            Captain
            Captain
            Posts: 4581
            Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2019 9:42 pm
            Location: Dagenham
            Contact:
            Great Britain

            Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

            Post by RangerNeil »

            To appreciate the Dune movies you really need to have read the books first. Otherwise much will not make sense. So much has to be left out for the films. Like LotR - Peter Jackson had to break that into 3 seperate films, each nearly 3 hours long and still missed parts of the book out..
            The new Dunes miss out the back story of the great houses, spend too much time on the Bene Gesserit back story at the expense of the Fedaykeen and why House Atrides and House Harkonnen hate each other and so forth. And theres virtually no explanation of why the spice Melange is so valuable. Special effects are good though! :)
              Neil (yet another one...)

              On the board now:

              Airfix 1/35 Alvis Stalwart Mk2 FV622
              Hobby Boss 1/350 Surcouf
              Hobby Boss 1/350 Soviet Alfa class
              Hobby Boss 1/350 USN Los Angeles
              Mikro Mir 1/350 HMS M1


              Scalemates stash info
              =58417&fkSTASHSTATUS[]=58417-Stash&page=stash]Scalemates Stash manager
              User avatar
              Stokesy44
              Major General
              Major General
              Posts: 8679
              Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
              Location: The Midlands, UK
              Great Britain

              Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

              Post by Stokesy44 »

              RangerNeil wrote: Mon Mar 02, 2026 7:01 pm To appreciate the Dune movies you really need to have read the books first. Otherwise much will not make sense. So much has to be left out for the films. Like LotR - Peter Jackson had to break that into 3 seperate films, each nearly 3 hours long and still missed parts of the book out..
              The new Dunes miss out the back story of the great houses, spend too much time on the Bene Gesserit back story at the expense of the Fedaykeen and why House Atrides and House Harkonnen hate each other and so forth. And theres virtually no explanation of why the spice Melange is so valuable. Special effects are good though! :)
              When LOTR came out I avoided the books and put my faith in the Director. The films stand by themselves and while I understand a lot was left out, its the people writing the adapted screenplay's job to make a coherent movie people who have not read the books can still enjoy. I actually prefer the extended versions as I feel they really add to the movies.

              No one is infallible though. I thought Jackson completely dropped the ball with the Hobbit films. No way that little book has enough for nearly 10 hours worth of film. Absolute hubris. And what they did with the frame settings made my eyes bleed :doh:
              Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
              User avatar
              RangerNeil
              Captain
              Captain
              Posts: 4581
              Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2019 9:42 pm
              Location: Dagenham
              Contact:
              Great Britain

              Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

              Post by RangerNeil »

              Stokesy44 wrote: Tue Mar 03, 2026 5:48 pm
              RangerNeil wrote: Mon Mar 02, 2026 7:01 pm To appreciate the Dune movies you really need to have read the books first. Otherwise much will not make sense. So much has to be left out for the films. Like LotR - Peter Jackson had to break that into 3 seperate films, each nearly 3 hours long and still missed parts of the book out..
              The new Dunes miss out the back story of the great houses, spend too much time on the Bene Gesserit back story at the expense of the Fedaykeen and why House Atrides and House Harkonnen hate each other and so forth. And theres virtually no explanation of why the spice Melange is so valuable. Special effects are good though! :)
              When LOTR came out I avoided the books and put my faith in the Director. The films stand by themselves and while I understand a lot was left out, its the people writing the adapted screenplay's job to make a coherent movie people who have not read the books can still enjoy. I actually prefer the extended versions as I feel they really add to the movies.

              No one is infallible though. I thought Jackson completely dropped the ball with the Hobbit films. No way that little book has enough for nearly 10 hours worth of film. Absolute hubris. And what they did with the frame settings made my eyes bleed :doh:
              The LotR book followed me around the world - it was read and re-read at every opportunity. On one rather memorable occassion the officer i/c the patrol rather sarcastically asked if it would be too much trouble to put the book away and start returning fire. Can't think what he was so upset about....
              The LotR films do flow - and flow well, if you haven't read the books. If you have read them the ending of film 3 is a complete cods. In the book Saruman and Wormtongue have taken over the Shire and were despoiling it so the returning Hobbits had to fight those two and restore the Shire. Frodo then goes to the Grey Havens.
              The first two films the deletion of scenes is virtually invisible.

              The Hobbit - different story - parts were removed and the jump between scenes was very noticeable. And don't get me started on the addition of the Tauriel character - even if she was rather tasty looking. For me the best part of the Hobbit was the sequence in the mines of Moriah. :) And, of course, the scenes where Smaug bites the dust - or lake water....
                Neil (yet another one...)

                On the board now:

                Airfix 1/35 Alvis Stalwart Mk2 FV622
                Hobby Boss 1/350 Surcouf
                Hobby Boss 1/350 Soviet Alfa class
                Hobby Boss 1/350 USN Los Angeles
                Mikro Mir 1/350 HMS M1


                Scalemates stash info
                =58417&fkSTASHSTATUS[]=58417-Stash&page=stash]Scalemates Stash manager
                NoelSmith
                Sergeant First Class
                Sergeant First Class
                Posts: 313
                Joined: Sat Feb 21, 2015 2:35 pm
                Great Britain

                Re: ISM Movie Night (just for giggles)

                Post by NoelSmith »

                I can remember seeing Disney's 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea in the cinema way back when I was still at school.
                Having watched it a few times since I still feel that is the best film based on that particular Jules Verne novel.
                James Mason's enigmatic portrayal of Captain Nemo has not been surpassed in my opinion.
                On TV a couple of years ago Around the World in 80 Days was serialised in BBC TC with David Tennant playing Phineas Fogg. In the very last episode after completing his journey he was sat in the Reform Club reading a newspaper article and remarked about reports in it about a sea monster attacking shipping in the Pacific. Was this a subtle hint about a new 20.000 Leagues series to come I wonder ?

                Recently my daughter bought me an omnibus book with all of Jules Verne's novels in it. Great reads considering when written.
                I also have another omnibus book with all of H.G. Wells' works in it.
                Post Reply

                Return to “Non Modelling Chat”